regression-tests

Rendering Regression Tests

Tests live in Tests/Mapsui.Rendering.Skia.Tests. They render every sample to a PNG and compare it pixel-by-pixel against a stored reference image.

---

Running

# All regression tests
dotnet test Tests/Mapsui.Rendering.Skia.Tests --filter "TestSampleAsync"

# Single sample (fastest for targeted changes)
dotnet test Tests/Mapsui.Rendering.Skia.Tests --filter "FullyQualifiedName~CalloutSample"

---

Results

Image paths:

• Generated: Tests/Mapsui.Rendering.Skia.Tests/bin/Debug/net9.0/Resources/Images/GeneratedRegression/
• Reference: Tests/Mapsui.Rendering.Skia.Tests/Resources/Images/OriginalRegression/

---

Updating reference images after intentional changes

Only run this script when you have made a deliberate functional rendering change (e.g. fixing a visual bug, changing a style default, adding a new rendering feature). Do not run it to "fix" failures caused by renderer differences — if the experimental renderer produces different output for a standard sample, that is a bug to be fixed in the renderer, not papered over with new reference images. There is only one set of reference images. The experimental renderer is expected to produce pixel-identical output to the standard renderer for all samples that are not in ExperimentalOnlySamples.

.\Scripts\CopyGeneratedImagesOverOriginalImages.ps1

Then run git diff --name-only and revert every image that was not affected by your change — avoid committing unrelated binary diffs.

Alternatively, copy a single image manually:

Copy-Item "Tests\Mapsui.Rendering.Skia.Tests\bin\Debug\net9.0\Resources\Images\GeneratedRegression\MySample.Regression.png" `
          "Tests\Mapsui.Rendering.Skia.Tests\Resources\Images\OriginalRegression\MySample.Regression.png" -Force

---

Standard vs. experimental renderer

The test suite can run with either renderer. The active renderer is determined by config files at the repository root, searched in priority order:

1. config.local.json at the repository root (git-ignored, per-machine override)
2. config.json at the repository root (committed — default experimentalRenderer: false)

CI always runs with the standard renderer (experimentalRenderer: false). Do not assume CI uses the experimental renderer.

To run locally with the experimental renderer, create config.local.json at the repository root:

{ "experimentalRenderer": true }

This file is git-ignored.

---

Samples that require the experimental renderer

The standard renderer does not support Font.FontSource, RichTextKit BiDi, or emoji rendering. Samples that require any of these must be added to ExperimentalOnlySamples in MapRegressionTests.cs:

public static ISampleBase[] ExperimentalOnlySamples =>
[
    new CalloutWrapAroundSample(),   // FontSource + Chinese text
    new CustomFontWidgetSample(),    // FontSource for Arabic and Chinese widgets
    new RightToLeftSample(),         // FontSource for Arabic
    new EmojiSample(),               // RTK emoji/font-fallback
];

When IsExperimentalRenderer = false (CI), these samples are excluded from the test run. When IsExperimentalRenderer = true, they are included and their reference images must have been generated with the experimental renderer.

If you add a sample that uses FontSource, RTK, or emoji — always add it to ExperimentalOnlySamples.

---

FontSource — common pitfalls

FontSource allows embedding custom fonts. Several things can silently fail:

TTF vs OTF

SKTypeface.FromStream only works with TTF (0x00 0x01 0x00 0x00 magic bytes). OTF/CFF files (magic OTTO = 0x4F 0x54 0x54 0x4F) return null silently. Variable fonts in TTF format work fine.

Always verify font format before embedding:

$bytes = [System.IO.File]::ReadAllBytes("MyFont.ttf")
"Magic: 0x{0:X2} 0x{1:X2} 0x{2:X2} 0x{3:X2}" -f $bytes[0], $bytes[1], $bytes[2], $bytes[3]
# Must be: 0x00 0x01 0x00 0x00 (TTF) or 0x74 0x72 0x75 0x65 (truetype)
# NOT:     0x4F 0x54 0x54 0x4F (OTF/CFF — won't work with SKTypeface.FromStream)

FetchAllFontDataAsync in tests

Regression tests call await map.RenderService.FontSourceCache.FetchAllFontDataAsync() before rendering (see MapRegressionTests.cs). This populates the font cache synchronously. In production the cache is populated by DataFetcher on viewport change — there is no need to call it manually outside tests.

Renderer must support FontSource

Only Mapsui.Experimental.Rendering.Skia honours Font.FontSource. The standard renderer (Mapsui.Rendering.Skia) ignores it and falls back to FontFamily / system font. If glyphs render as boxes with the standard renderer, that is expected — add the sample to ExperimentalOnlySamples.

Why Arabic may appear correct while Chinese shows boxes (standard renderer): Windows ships with system Arabic fonts (e.g. Segoe UI, Arial Unicode MS) so the standard renderer's FontFamily fallback accidentally finds a matching glyph. It does not ship with a CJK font by default, so Chinese characters render as boxes. This asymmetry can mask the fact that FontSource is being ignored — the Arabic "works" for the wrong reason. If a sample uses FontSource for any script, add it to ExperimentalOnlySamples regardless of whether individual scripts appear to render correctly on the standard renderer.

Embedded resource path

The URI must exactly match the fully-qualified assembly resource name:

embedded://Mapsui.Samples.Common.Resources.Fonts.NotoSansArabic-Regular.ttf

The project .csproj must have a matching <EmbeddedResource> entry. Mismatch produces null bytes with no error.

---

Diagnosing a broken rendering test

1. Check which renderer is active: read Tests/Mapsui.Rendering.Skia.Tests/bin/Debug/net9.0/config.local.json and config.json.
2. Visually compare the generated image against the reference image — the failure message prints both paths.
3. Font issues: if text is boxes, the typeface is null. Check: (a) TTF magic bytes, (b) FetchAllFontDataAsync was awaited, (c) Font.FontSource URI matches the embedded resource name, (d) renderer is experimental.
4. Experimental renderer failures: the experimental renderer must produce pixel-identical output to the standard renderer for all samples not in ExperimentalOnlySamples. If a sample fails only with the experimental renderer, that is a bug in the experimental renderer — investigate and fix it. Common causes: a custom style renderer registered only on Mapsui.Rendering.Skia.MapRenderer but not on Mapsui.Experimental.Rendering.Skia.MapRenderer (fix: add the registration call for both); or a genuine rendering difference in a two-step drawable renderer.

---

Adding a new sample with a regression test

1. Implement the sample (see copilot-instructions for auto-registration via source generator).
2. Run dotnet test Tests/Mapsui.Rendering.Skia.Tests --filter "FullyQualifiedName~MySample".
3. Result should be Inconclusive (no reference yet).
4. Visually inspect the generated image in GeneratedRegression/.
5. Copy it to OriginalRegression/ (manually or via CopyGeneratedImagesOverOriginalImages.ps1).
6. Re-run — should now be Passed.
7. If the sample uses FontSource / RTK / emoji, add it to ExperimentalOnlySamples in MapRegressionTests.cs and generate the reference with the experimental renderer.