Nw Tr Review Criteria
Testing & Qualitynw-tr-review-criteriaNw Tr Review Criteria is an Agent Skill for testing & quality published in the nWave-ai/nWave repository on GitHub: a SKILL.md instruction file an AI agent can load to do this task.
Review dimensions and scoring for root cause analysis quality assessment
How to use this skill
Bring this guide into your coding agent with a prompt tailored to the tool you use.
- Open your project in Codex.
- Copy and paste the prompt below.
- Review files and risks before approving any action.
Inspect the Agent Skill at https://github.com/nWave-ai/nWave/blob/HEAD/plugins/nw/skills/nw-tr-review-criteria/SKILL.md and all supporting files. Report provenance, permissions, scripts, dependencies, and security risks. Propose an exact installation into .agents/skills/nw-tr-review-criteria, but wait for my approval before writing files or running scripts.
Copying this prompt does not install or run the skill. Review third-party files before use.
Troubleshooter Review Criteria
Review dimensions and scoring for root cause analysis quality assessment.
Dimension 1: Causality Logic
Check each WHY-to-WHY link.
Pass: logical mechanism (not just correlation) | no skipped steps | alternatives considered/eliminated | chain reads coherently both directions
Failures: correlation assumed as causation | causal chain gaps | single-path tunnel vision (first plausible cause accepted)
Severity: Critical -- wrong root cause = ineffective fixes.
Dimension 2: Evidence Quality
Verify findings grounded in observable data.
Pass: each WHY cites specific evidence (logs, metrics, config, repro steps) | evidence verifiable by third party | timeline supports causality | hypotheses marked unverified
Failures: "Probably because..." without data | vague references ("logs show issues") | mixing facts with speculation unlabeled
Severity: High -- unreliable analysis undermines trust.
Dimension 3: Alternative Hypotheses
Verify competing explanations explored.
Pass: 2+ alternatives at WHY 1-3 | each pursued or eliminated with evidence | "why not" reasoning documented
Failures: stops at first plausible cause | alternatives mentioned but unevaluated | confirmation bias
Severity: High -- may miss actual root cause.
Dimension 4: Five-WHY Depth
Verify analysis reaches fundamental causes.
Pass: each branch reaches WHY 5 (or justifies stopping with evidence) | final causes are actionable | causes explain symptoms when traced forward
Failures: stopping at WHY 2-3 | WHY 5 vague/philosophical not actionable | branches abandoned
Severity: High -- shallow analysis = band-aid fixes that recur.
Dimension 5: Completeness and Coverage
Verify all symptoms accounted for.
Pass: all symptoms have causal branch | root causes collectively explain all | no orphan symptoms | cross-cause validation (no contradictions)
Failures: symptoms ignored | root causes explain primary but not secondary | contradictory causes without reconciliation
Severity: Medium -- incomplete analysis leaves unaddressed failures.
Dimension 6: Solution Traceability
Verify solutions map to root causes.
Pass: every root cause has solution | immediate mitigations vs permanent fixes distinguished | no orphan solutions | prevention addresses systemic factors
Failures: solutions address symptoms not causes | root cause without fix | generic recommendations untied to findings
Severity: Medium -- untraceable solutions are guesses.
Review Output Format
review_id: "rca_rev_{timestamp}"
reviewer: "nw-troubleshooter-reviewer"
dimensions:
causality_logic:
score: 0-10
issues: [{issue, severity, recommendation}]
evidence_quality:
score: 0-10
issues: [{issue, severity, recommendation}]
alternative_hypotheses:
score: 0-10
issues: [{issue, severity, recommendation}]
five_why_depth:
score: 0-10
issues: [{issue, severity, recommendation}]
completeness:
score: 0-10
issues: [{issue, severity, recommendation}]
solution_traceability:
score: 0-10
issues: [{issue, severity, recommendation}]
overall_score: "average of dimension scores"
approval_status: "approved | revisions_required"
summary: "1-2 sentence assessment"
Scoring Guide
- 9-10: Exemplary. No issues or minor style only.
- 7-8: Good. Minor issues not affecting conclusions.
- 5-6: Adequate. Issues weaken but don't invalidate.
- 3-4: Poor. Issues may lead to incorrect conclusions.
- 1-2: Failing. Fundamental flaws invalidate analysis.
Approval threshold: overall >= 7 and no dimension below 5.