# Jaar Workflow

> Jaar Workflow is an Agent Skill for productivity published in the brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills repository on GitHub: a SKILL.md instruction file an AI agent can load to do this task.

Use as the entry point for any Journal of the American Academy of Religion (JAAR) manuscript. Routes to the right JAAR sub-skill by lifecycle stage, and enforces the journal's gatekeeping demand up front — the article must speak to a question of broad and fundamental interest to the study of religion, not just a subfield. It dispatches; it does not draft content.

- Skill name: `jaar-workflow`
- Category: [Productivity](https://www.openparable.com/skill/productivity/1)
- Source: https://github.com/brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/blob/HEAD/Journal-of-the-American-Academy-of-Religion-Skills/skills/jaar-workflow/SKILL.md
- Repository: brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills (805 GitHub stars when collected)

## SKILL.md

# JAAR Workflow Router (jaar-workflow)

The orchestrator for a JAAR submission. JAAR's editorial office reads **every** submission and, before
any peer review, asks one decisive question: does this article address a problem of **"broad and
fundamental interest to the study of religion"** and reach **beyond the sub-specialty** it comes from?
If not, the editor **returns it for reframing before review**. The router makes you answer that first.

## When to trigger

- Starting a JAAR article and unsure where to begin
- Mid-project and unsure which skill applies next
- A draft reads as a contribution to one tradition/subfield only (reframing risk)
- Returning with a decision letter (route to `jaar-revision-and-response`)

## The gate before everything: the reframing test

Before drafting, state in one sentence what your article teaches **the study of religion as a whole**
— not just Buddhist studies, or American religious history, or philosophy of religion. If you cannot,
go to `jaar-topic-selection` and `jaar-scholarly-positioning` and reframe **now**; the editor will
otherwise bounce it back unreviewed.

## Routing map (stage → skill)

```text
Idea / fit + reframing?           → jaar-topic-selection
Where does it sit in the field?   → jaar-scholarly-positioning
What's the argument / "point"?    → jaar-argument-development
Texts, traditions, fieldwork?     → jaar-sources-and-evidence
Theory & method (reflexivity)?    → jaar-theory-and-method
How is the essay built?           → jaar-structure-and-exposition
Does the prose read well?         → jaar-writing-style
In-text citations + style?        → jaar-citation-and-style
How will it be judged?            → jaar-review-process
Ready to submit?                  → jaar-submission
Got a decision / R&R?             → jaar-revision-and-response
```

## Default order

`topic-selection → scholarly-positioning → argument-development → sources-and-evidence →
theory-and-method → structure-and-exposition → writing-style → citation-and-style → review-process →
submission → revision-and-response`

## Anti-patterns

- Drafting a subfield-only article and hoping the editor sends it out anyway (it won't)
- Treating JAAR like an empirical-social-science venue (no datasets/statistics/replication here)
- Using footnotes for citations (JAAR uses **in-text author-date**; see `jaar-citation-and-style`)
- Planning an unsolicited book review (JAAR reviews are **commissioned only**)

## Output format

```
【Stage】fit / positioning / argument / sources / theory-method / structure / prose / citation / review / submit / revise
【Reframing test】one sentence on what it teaches the study of religion writ large
【Route to】jaar-<skill>
【Why】one line
【Then】the next skill after that
```

## Symptom-to-skill dispatch table

When an author arrives mid-project with a complaint rather than a clean stage, route by symptom. These
are the recurring failure signatures at the AAR/Oxford University Press flagship.

| Symptom the author reports | Route to | Why |
|----------------------------|----------|-----|
| "A reader called it descriptive" | jaar-argument-development | Needs a contestable point |
| "Only specialists will care" | jaar-topic-selection → jaar-scholarly-positioning | Reframe for broad interest |
| "Told it's undertheorized / confessional" | jaar-theory-and-method | Make method load-bearing; redraw the about/for line |
| "Translation/source was challenged" | jaar-sources-and-evidence | Originals, provenance, representativeness |
| "Readers get lost in the sections" | jaar-structure-and-exposition | Throughline and signposting |
| "Footnotes for citations flagged" | jaar-citation-and-style | Convert to in-text author-date |
| "Identity visible in the file" | jaar-submission | Anonymize for double-anonymous review |
| "R&R letter arrived" | jaar-revision-and-response | Point-by-point, protect broad significance |

## Worked vignette: routing a stalled manuscript

An author says: "My essay on a Daoist liturgical manual is done, but a colleague said it only matters
to Daoist-studies people, and another said the citations look wrong." The router resolves this in order:

- **Reframing test first.** Can the author state in one sentence what it teaches the study of religion
  writ large? Not yet — so route to `jaar-topic-selection` (reframe around what the manual shows about
  the analytic of "liturgy" or text-as-ritual-object) and then `jaar-scholarly-positioning`.
- **Then the surface flag.** The citation complaint routes to `jaar-citation-and-style` (footnote-to-
  in-text conversion) — but only after the Gate-1 reframing risk is handled, since style cannot save a
  subfield-bound piece.
- **Sequence out.** From there the default order resumes: argument → sources → theory-method →
  structure → writing-style, then review-process and submission.

## Router anti-pattern → correction

| Author's instinct | Correction |
|-------------------|------------|
| "Fix the citations first, then worry about framing" | Clear the Gate-1 reframing risk first; style is downstream |
| "Skip positioning, my sources are strong" | Strong sources don't establish broad significance |
| "Submit and let the editor reframe it" | The editor returns it unreviewed; reframe before upload |
| "Plan a book review as an entry point" | Reviews are commissioned only — not a route in |

Hedged calibration: this router encodes the journal's stated gatekeeping logic (broad-interest screen,
double-anonymous review, in-text citation, commissioned reviews) and the typical skill sequence;
treat the ordering as advisory and confirm any process specifics against the journal's current
submission guidelines.

## Supplementary resources

- [`../../resources/external_tools.md`](../../resources/external_tools.md) — reference and research tools for the study of religion
- [`../../resources/official-source-map.md`](../../resources/official-source-map.md) — official JAAR URLs behind every fact in this pack

---

Source: https://www.openparable.com/skill/productivity/jaar-workflow (OpenParable). Cite the canonical URL above.
