# Military Justice Deliberation Process

> Military Justice Deliberation Process is an Agent Skill for general use published in the baojie/shiji-kb repository on GitHub: a SKILL.md instruction file an AI agent can load to do this task.

Use when deciding the fate of a defeated general who returns after losing their forces. Convenes advisors, weighs strict versus lenient views, and defers to higher authority rather than unilateral execution.

- Skill name: `military-justice-deliberation-process`
- Category: [Others](https://www.openparable.com/skill/others/1)
- Source: https://github.com/baojie/shiji-kb/blob/HEAD/kg/ontology/ontology-v1/skus/procedural/skill_219/SKILL.md
- Repository: baojie/shiji-kb (2,300 GitHub stars when collected)

## SKILL.md

# Military Justice Deliberation Process

## Overview
A structured decision-making procedure for handling defeated generals who return to camp after losing their forces. Based on Wei Qing's handling of General Su Jian.

## Steps

1. **Receive the Returning Officer**
   - Allow the defeated commander to return and report
   - Do not immediately execute or punish

2. **Convene a Council of Advisors**
   - Gather legal officers (正), secretaries (长史), and advisors (议郎)
   - Present the case for deliberation

3. **Hear Competing Arguments**
   - **Strict View**: Argue for execution to establish authority and deterrence
   - **Lenient View**: Argue that the officer fought bravely against overwhelming odds and returned out of loyalty

4. **Consider Key Factors**
   - Circumstances of defeat (outnumbered, fought valiantly)
   - Officer's loyalty (returned rather than defected)
   - Precedent and impact on morale

5. **Defer to Higher Authority**
   - As a field commander, avoid unilateral execution of high-ranking officers
   - Escort the accused to the sovereign for final judgment
   - This demonstrates respect for hierarchy and avoids overstepping authority

## Decision Principle
"不患无威" - A true leader need not worry about lacking authority; executing subordinates to demonstrate power is unnecessary and may undermine trust.

## Expected Outcome
The sovereign makes the final decision, preserving chain of command while allowing for mercy or justice as appropriate.

## Verification
- Confirm both strict and lenient arguments were formally heard before reaching a recommendation
- Validate that the circumstances of defeat (odds faced, valor shown, loyalty in returning) were thoroughly investigated
- Check that the case was properly escalated to higher authority rather than resolved by field execution

---

Source: https://www.openparable.com/skill/others/military-justice-deliberation-process (OpenParable). Cite the canonical URL above.
